Google: Oracle's Java patent suit invalid

Google logoGoogle fired back at Oracle yesterday in their dispute over Java, claiming that Oracle had once criticized the licensing policies it now seeks to uphold.

The formal answer to Oracle's complaint over Google's alleged infringement of patents related to Java made its way into the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California late yesterday evening. Oracle, wielding patents it acquired along with Sun Microsystems in 2009, claimed in August that Google's implementation of the Dalvik virtual machine in Android--among other things--violated as many as seven patents. Google responded by denying Oracle's claims of infringement, and also asked Judge William Alsup to declare the patents invalid. In making its argument, Google pointed out that before Oracle acquired Sun, it was critical of the stance Sun assumed when it came to licensing a key part of the Java platform, a test compatibility kit needed to obtain an open-source license for the entire Java platform.

In its answer, Google claimed Sun released the specs for its Java virtual machine in a manner that allowed other software developers to build "clean-room implementations of Sun's Java specifications." However, it pointed out that Sun was unwilling to release the test compatibility kit (TCK) under the same open-source license that it was willing to release the rest of the Java platform, basically ensuring that Sun would receive some licensing revenue from Java and could control which projects could be deemed compatible with Java.

In 2009, Google said Oracle criticized Sun for this stance by lending its support to the platform advocated by the Java Community Process standards group, which wrote: "TCK licenses must not be used to discriminate against or restrict compatible implementations of Java specifications by including field of use restrictions on the tested implementations or otherwise. Licenses containing such limitations do not meet the requirements of the JSPA, the agreement under which the JCP operates, and violate the expectations of the Java community that JCP specs can be openly implemented."

However, once Oracle completed its acquisition of Sun later that year, it has "ignored the open source community's requests to fully open-source the Java platform," according to the answer.

The dispute seems likely to come down to the notion of just how "clean" Google's "clean-room implementation" of the Dalvik virtual machine really is. Dalvik allows software developers to use the Java programming language to write their apps for Android phones.

When Android was first announced, Sun executives were skeptical that Google could have really pulled off a truly clean implementation. Google noted that Dalvik includes technology developed by the Apache Software Foundation that received the full open-source license from Sun.

"Although software applications for the Android platform may be written in the Java programming language, the Dalvik bytecode is distinct and different from Java bytecode," Google wrote in its answer. "The Dalvik VM is not a Java VM."

Source: CNET

Tags: Google, Java, Oracle

Comments
Add comment

Your name:
Sign in with:
or
Your comment:


Enter code:

E-mail (not required)
E-mail will not be disclosed to the third party


Last news

 
You can use a security key instead of having a code sent to your phone
 
Adobe says that the AI can now achieve the intended result in seconds
 
A new security protocol replacing the aging WPA2
 
Download and install at your own risk, of course
 
More iPhone parts likely to be produced by Samsung
 
Starting on Friday, video views on YouTube will start to be counted by the Official Charts Company
 
LG has already announced two new V-series members in 2018
 
The method is blocked and the hack doesn’t work, it adds
The Samsung Galaxy A5 (2017) Review
The evolution of the successful smartphone, now with a waterproof body and USB Type-C
February 7, 2017 /
Samsung Galaxy TabPro S - a tablet with the Windows-keyboard
The first Windows-tablet with the 12-inch display Super AMOLED
June 7, 2016 /
Keyboards for iOS
Ten iOS keyboards review
July 18, 2015 /
Samsung E1200 Mobile Phone Review
A cheap phone with a good screen
March 8, 2015 / 4
Creative Sound Blaster Z sound card review
Good sound for those who are not satisfied with the onboard solution
September 25, 2014 / 2
Samsung Galaxy Gear: Smartwatch at High Price
The first smartwatch from Samsung - almost a smartphone with a small body
December 19, 2013 /
 
 

News Archive

 
 
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    




Poll

Do you use microSD card with your phone?
or leave your own version in comments (10)