Wikipedia editors question site's blackout

Wikipedia editors question site's blackoutCan the world live without Wikipedia for a day? The shutdown of one of the Internet's most-visited sites is not sitting well with some of its volunteer editors, who say the protest of anti-piracy legislation could threaten the credibility of their work.

"My main concern is that it puts the organization in the role of advocacy, and that's a slippery slope," said editor Robert Lawton, a Michigan computer consultant who would prefer that the encyclopedia stick to being a neutral repository of knowledge. "Before we know it, we're blacked out because we want to save the whales."

The protest is aimed at the Stop Online Piracy Act in the House of Representatives and the Protect Intellectual Property Act under consideration in the Senate. Both bills are designed to crack down on sales of pirated American products overseas, and they have the support of the film and music industry. Among the opponents are many Internet companies such as Google, Facebook, Yahoo, Twitter, eBay and AOL. They say the bills would hurt the industry and infringe on free-speech rights.

Wikipedia's English-language site shut down at midnight Eastern Standard Time Tuesday (0500 GMT Wednesday) and the organization said it would stay down for 24 hours.

Wikipedia blackout

Instead of encyclopedia articles, visitors to the site saw a stark black-and-white page with the message: "Imagine a world without free knowledge." It carried a link to information about the two congressional bills and details about how to reach lawmakers.

It is the first time the English site has been blacked out. Wikipedia's Italian site came down once briefly to protest an Internet censorship bill put forward by the Berlusconi government. The bill did not advance.

The shutdown adds to a growing body of critics who are speaking out against the legislation. But some editors are so uneasy with the move that they have blacked out their own user profile pages or resigned their administrative rights on the site to protest. Some likened the site's decision to fighting censorship with censorship.

One of the site's own "five pillars" of conduct says that Wikipedia "is written from a neutral point of view." The site strives to "avoid advocacy, and we characterize information and issues rather than debate them."

Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales argues that the site can maintain neutrality in content even as it takes public positions on issues.

"The encyclopedia will always be neutral. The community need not be, not when the encyclopedia is threatened," he tweeted.

The Wikimedia Foundation, which administers the site, announced the blackout late Monday, after polling its community of volunteer contributors and editors and getting responses from 1,800 of them.

"If passed, this legislation will harm the free and open Internet and bring about new tools for censorship of international websites inside the United States," the foundation said.

Social news website Reddit.com is shutting down for 12 hours on Wednesday, but most companies are staying up. Google Inc.'s home page, with its logo covered by a black rectangle, linked to a petition urging Congress: "Don't censor the Web."

Dick Costollo, CEO of Twitter, said he opposes the legislation as well, but shutting down the service was out of the question.

"Closing a global business in reaction to single-issue national politics is foolish," Costollo tweeted.

Since Wikimedia depends on a small army of volunteers who create and update articles, it's particularly concerned about a lack of exemptions in the bills for sites where users might contribute copyrighted content. Today, it has no obligation under U.S. law except removing that content if a copyright holder complains. But under the House version of the bill, it could be shut down unless it polices its own pages.

The bill's prospects appeared to be dimming. On Saturday, Rep. Darrell Issa, a California Republican, said the bill would not move to the House floor for a vote unless consensus is reached. However, Lamar Smith, a Texas Republican, said work on the bill would resume next month.

The White House raised concerns over the weekend, pledging to work with Congress to battle piracy and counterfeiting while defending free expression, privacy and innovation in the Internet. The administration signaled it might use its veto power, if necessary.

That the bill seems unlikely to pass is another reason Lawton opposes the blackout.

"I think there are far more important things for the organization to focus aside from legislation that isn't likely to pass anyway," he said. He's been contributing to Wikipedia for eight years.

Danny Chia, another contributor to the site, said he had mixed feelings about the blackout. The neutrality applies to the content, but a lot of people interpret it as being about the site as a whole, said the California software engineer.

In an online discussion, others raised the same point about the blackout: Appearances matter, and if the audience sees Wikipedia taking a stand, it might not believe the articles are objective, either.

Wikipedia has seen a small decline in participation, from a peak of 100,000 active editors a year ago to about 90,000 now. Wikimedia Foundation blames this mainly on outdated editing tools, and believes it can get the number growing again with software upgrades.

Tags: Wikipedia

Comments
Add comment

Your name:
Sign in with:
or
Your comment:


Enter code:

E-mail (not required)
E-mail will not be disclosed to the third party


Ardian#10 0
Le tour de la question je crois que c'est vite dit .e0 mon sens le blog n'a pas <a href="http://aluqmafsu.com"> eoxplit</a>e9 le millie8me de ses possibilite9s .au-dele0 des aventures personnelles, sexuelles ou non de nos che8res sЕ“urs, c'e9tait un ve9ritable outil d'e9ducation (oui), et d'e9changes pour la communaute9 afro telle qu'on la souhaite Gangoueus, il m'arrive de lire les anciens articles parce que je vis ou je rencontre des situations qui y sont e9voque9es et e0 chaque fois je me rends compte qu'elles traitent avec acuite9, de certains sujets de notre socie9te9 actuelle avec nos re9alite9s d'afro descendants et puis je trouve qu'elles ont un ve9ritable talent e0 faire les choses .Etum: sorte de chevalier blanc des tantines ?
Reply 
Ardian#20 0
Le tour de la question je crois que c'est vite dit .e0 mon sens le blog n'a pas <a href="http://aluqmafsu.com"> eoxplit</a>e9 le millie8me de ses possibilite9s .au-dele0 des aventures personnelles, sexuelles ou non de nos che8res sЕ“urs, c'e9tait un ve9ritable outil d'e9ducation (oui), et d'e9changes pour la communaute9 afro telle qu'on la souhaite Gangoueus, il m'arrive de lire les anciens articles parce que je vis ou je rencontre des situations qui y sont e9voque9es et e0 chaque fois je me rends compte qu'elles traitent avec acuite9, de certains sujets de notre socie9te9 actuelle avec nos re9alite9s d'afro descendants et puis je trouve qu'elles ont un ve9ritable talent e0 faire les choses .Etum: sorte de chevalier blanc des tantines ?
Reply 
Ardian#30 0
Le tour de la question je crois que c'est vite dit .e0 mon sens le blog n'a pas <a href="http://aluqmafsu.com"> eoxplit</a>e9 le millie8me de ses possibilite9s .au-dele0 des aventures personnelles, sexuelles ou non de nos che8res sЕ“urs, c'e9tait un ve9ritable outil d'e9ducation (oui), et d'e9changes pour la communaute9 afro telle qu'on la souhaite Gangoueus, il m'arrive de lire les anciens articles parce que je vis ou je rencontre des situations qui y sont e9voque9es et e0 chaque fois je me rends compte qu'elles traitent avec acuite9, de certains sujets de notre socie9te9 actuelle avec nos re9alite9s d'afro descendants et puis je trouve qu'elles ont un ve9ritable talent e0 faire les choses .Etum: sorte de chevalier blanc des tantines ?
Reply 

Last news

 
Consumer group recommends iPhone 8 over anniversary model
 
LTE connections wherever you go and instant waking should come to regular PCs, too
 
That fiction is slowly becoming a reality
 
The Snapdragon 845 octa-core SoC includes the Snapdragon X20 LTE modem
 
Human moderators can help make YouTube a safer place for everyone
 
Google says Progressive Web Apps are the future of app-like webpages
 
All 2018 models to sport the 'notch'
 
The biggest exchange in South Korea, where the BTC/KRW pair is at $14,700 now
The Samsung Galaxy A5 (2017) Review
The evolution of the successful smartphone, now with a waterproof body and USB Type-C
February 7, 2017 /
Samsung Galaxy TabPro S - a tablet with the Windows-keyboard
The first Windows-tablet with the 12-inch display Super AMOLED
June 7, 2016 /
Keyboards for iOS
Ten iOS keyboards review
July 18, 2015 /
Samsung E1200 Mobile Phone Review
A cheap phone with a good screen
March 8, 2015 / 4
Creative Sound Blaster Z sound card review
Good sound for those who are not satisfied with the onboard solution
September 25, 2014 / 2
Samsung Galaxy Gear: Smartwatch at High Price
The first smartwatch from Samsung - almost a smartphone with a small body
December 19, 2013 /
 
 

News Archive

 
 
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      




Poll

Do you use microSD card with your phone?
or leave your own version in comments (4)