Samsung says it patented iPhone's best features before Apple did

Samsung logoThe gargantuan Apple v. Samsung trial isn't just about Apple's claims that Samsung copied its flagship products. After it was sued, Samsung used its own patents to go after Apple, and the San Jose jury will soon issue a verdict on both sides' claims.

Today Samsung unleashed its counterattack, putting an expert on the stand that accused Apple of infringing three patents with incredibly wide-ranging claims to basic smartphone functions.

The Korean electronics giant claims to have one patent that covers multi-tasking while playing music (No. 7,698,711); another that covers "bookmarking" the last-viewed photo in a smartphone for easy retrieval (7,456,893); and even one that the company says covers sending an e-mail with a photo attached (7,577,460).

A Samsung expert witness, Harvard Professor Woodward Yang, walked the jury through the claims of the patents he said were infringed by Apple products like the iPhone 3GS, iPhone 4, iPad 2, and the 4th-generation iPod touch. Yang, who was paid $550 an hour for his work on the case, described each claim in simple terms, and narrated along as videos on the slide showed a demonstration of how each patent was used by Apple products.

"You're looking at a picture, and if you go to do another function—you've lost your place," said Yang, describing the '893 patent. "The idea was, let's have a bookmark."

A video played for the jury, showing a screen split four ways: iPhones and an iPad all viewed a vacation photo, then took a photo of an orange. After going back to the photo gallery, the vacation photo came up immediately.

"That's very convenient," explained Yang. "Without this invention, you'd now be looking at the picture of the orange."

(The iPhone 3G wasn't accused on that particular patent, since the feature was added later.)

Later, Yang walked through Samsung's music-multitasking patent. A video showed a user picking a song, then going back to e-mail and other applications.

"I could be reviewing my mail while I'm listening to Bruce Springsteen," said Yang.

The features on display in the three patents were only added to the iPhone after they were patented by Samsung, the company's lawyers alleged.

On cross-exam, Apple's lawyer, Bill Lee, didn't challenge the Samsung patents directly. Instead, he suggested that Apple's devices don't meet terminology found in the patents, like a "silent mode." He also noted that Yang has made about $200,000 working on this lawsuit, and a similar amount in a lawsuit involving Nokia.

The Samsung counter-attack isn't over; in addition to the user-interface patents that Yang testified on, the Korean company has patents it says cover the 3G wireless standard that Apple is infringing.

Making a case for damages on specific user-interface features can be wildly speculative. An Apple expert in this case believes that the patents involved in this case add $90 per smartphone. In a smartphone trial scheduled to start earlier this year, Apple v. Motorola, the judge overseeing the case deemed the damages arguments so weak he canceled the trial altogether.

The way the jury will see a strategy like Samsung's is hard to predict. Patent counter-attacks can be seen as vindictive, or they can convince a jury that both sides' claims have a kind of parity, with each having important intellectual property.

Testimony continued in the afternoon, with a Samsung designer named Jeeyeun Wang taking the stand.

Source: Ars Technica

Tags: Apple, legal action, Samsung

Add comment

Your name:
Sign in with:
Your comment:

Enter code:

E-mail (not required)
E-mail will not be disclosed to the third party

Last news

Sales of new models way below those of 2017 generation
The new Windows 10 browser will run on the Chromium engine
Google will shut the service down in April of 2019 instead of August as initially planned
The regular S10 will sport a 6.1-inch panel with the same front-facing camera design
The smartphone has a 6.4-inch Full HD+ (2340 x 1080 pixel) Infinity-O display
Google Play Services will deprecate the aging OS in newer releases
Apple might be looking to trial the feature on the iPad before iPhone
Toshiba, which released the world’s first 14TB nearline 3.5-inch and 26.1mm-height HDDs with 9-disk
The Samsung Galaxy A5 (2017) Review
The evolution of the successful smartphone, now with a waterproof body and USB Type-C
February 7, 2017 /
Samsung Galaxy TabPro S - a tablet with the Windows-keyboard
The first Windows-tablet with the 12-inch display Super AMOLED
June 7, 2016 /
Keyboards for iOS
Ten iOS keyboards review
July 18, 2015 /
Samsung E1200 Mobile Phone Review
A cheap phone with a good screen
March 8, 2015 / 4
Creative Sound Blaster Z sound card review
Good sound for those who are not satisfied with the onboard solution
September 25, 2014 / 2
Samsung Galaxy Gear: Smartwatch at High Price
The first smartwatch from Samsung - almost a smartphone with a small body
December 19, 2013 /

News Archive



Do you use microSD card with your phone?
or leave your own version in comments (11)